0411-5831271

15981556722

球员离开曼联就能踢得很好?麦克托米奈:这不是曼联的问题(离开曼联就能立刻起飞?麦克托米奈:问题不在曼联)

2026-01-12

Analyzing without network access

提醒

I think we can approach this without needing online access by offering potential analysis. The user seems to want to engage in discussion and might be prompted for specific aspects like original statements, background, viewpoints, or data. It’s a common narrative with selection bias and context regarding roles, tactics, injuries, and manager instability since 2013. I could highlight how McTominay's comments shift blame and suggest the importance of both club environment and player fit. I should also ask if they want a timeline of players who left since 2018.Exploring player performance after leaving

der

I want to outline potential reasons why players might perform better after leaving a club, but I should also provide counter-examples. I need to consider what McTominay likely means by his statements. Since my network access might be restricted, I can mention that I can compile a quick list from memory or ask the user if they want me to analyze specific players. I could also offer to translate information or draft a social media post expressing a viewpoint. Now, let’s respond!

我的理解:这是在回应“离开曼联就开窍”的叙事。麦克托米奈的意思是别把个体起伏都归因于曼联,更多是球员自身与环境匹配的问题。

几点简析

范德贝克等

如何看待麦克托米奈这句话

更多是球员

需要的话我可以:

  1. 按赛季列出近5—7年离队球员离前/离后关键数据对比(进球、助攻、xG、出场、伤停),给你一张速览表;
  2. 针对你关心的几位(比如卢卡库、迪马利亚、桑乔、范德贝克等)做战术适配的短评;
  3. 把这条观点整理成一段社媒帖或播客提纲。